WARNReviewer 1· 85% conf
The paper reports methods in sufficient mathematical detail for replication, but lacks a reporting guideline, does not register or pre-specify outcomes, and omits a formal limitations section (though some limitations are hinted in the comparison).
Evidence
direct quote[Sections 3 and 4]
“Theorem 1 Let Ξ z = ⟨ Ђ z , Ћ z , Њ z ⟩ ( z = 1 , 2 , . . . , Ķ ) be a group of T S P-FNs. Then , the T S P-FAAPMM operator's aggregated value utilizing Equation is still a T S P-FN and [Equation 11]”direct quote[Section 5, near end]
“The disadvantage of the established AGOs is undefined when one the N-MED and ABD are equal to zero, while employing T S P-FAAPWMM operators, and when the MED is equal to zero, it is undefined while employing T S P-FAAPWDMM operators.”direct quote[End of article (A Statement of Competing Interests, Declaration of competing interest)]
“The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.”PASSReviewer 2· 90% conf
Methods are thoroughly described, outcomes are fully reported, limitations are discussed, conclusions are proportional, and a COI statement is provided, though funding sources are not mentioned.
Evidence
direct quote[Section 8 (Comparative analysis, advantages and disadvantages)]
“The disadvantage of the established AGOs is undefined when one the N-MED and ABD are equal to zero, while employing T S P-FAAPWMM operators, and when the MED is equal to zero, it is undefined while employing T S P-FAAPWDMM operators.”direct quote[Declaration of competing interest]
“The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.”absence[Funding section (absent)]
No funding information is mentioned.WARNReviewer 3· 85% conf
Methods are mathematically detailed, limitations are discussed, and conclusions are proportional; however, the paper is not a clinical trial so trial_registration is n/a, and no reporting guideline is referenced (ARRIVE/CONSORT/PRISMA/STROBE not applicable to a pure-math study), but the major gap is that funding/COI statements are present but vague.
Evidence
paraphrase[Sections 3-5]
“Sections 3-5 provide complete definitions, theorems, and proofs for the proposed aggregation operators and the weighted operators.”direct quote[Section 8, paragraph 2]
“The disadvantage of the established AGOs is undefined when one the N-MED and ABD are equal to zero, while employing T S P-FAAPWMM operators, and when the MED is equal to zero, it is undefined while employing T S P-FAAPWDMM operators.”paraphrase[Declaration of competing interest, CRediT authorship contribution statement]
“The paper includes a 'Declaration of competing interest' stating no known competing financial interests, and a CRediT statement; no funding or grant numbers are provided.”